Parties rarely settle their dispute after the Supreme Court has agreed to hear their appeal and the case is scheduled for oral argument. Yet the parties in Mount Holly v. Mount Holly Gardens Citizens in Action Inc. did. Just weeks before their oral arguments would begin on December 4, 2013, Mount Holly Township settled its housing discrimination dispute with Mount Holly Gardens. Both sides settled late November 13, 2013. Why, after advocating at each level of appeal and finally receiving a highly sought after slot for oral argument in front of the Nation’s highest court, would these parties settle?